Michelle Williams shocked everyone when she appeared at the Independent Spirit Awards in 2007 with a new pixie cut. This was clearly not the Jen Lindley people had met on “Dawson’s Creek.”

Though this cut was reminiscent of Mia Farrow, circa “Rosemary’s Baby,” it seemed fresh and innovative on Williams. And though she returns to a longer look from time to time, Williams’ pixie is still one of the best looks on the red carpet (in our opinion).

Which do you like better: Michelle Williams with long hair or Michelle Williams with short hair? Leave your answer in the comments below.