Simpson is probably most popular as a redhead, but we think the color looks too “fake” and overwhelms her skin tone. “The red looks acceptable only because it is compensated for with the makeup choices, i.e. the lipstick,” says Pelusi. Luckily, the bright colors work to lighten up her skin tone and bring out her green eyes in this case.

Our humble opinion: “The red gives Simpson her own identity, and it goes well with her skin tone.” — Susan, Associate Editor

“Going this red is hard to pull off, and she does it beautifully.” — Anna, Assistant Editor

Next: Ashlee Simpson with black hair