We’re definitely not the hugest fans of this color (too drab and washed out, no?) but in this case, her makeup choices make it work. Robinson agrees, saying “the dark color isn’t my favorite but a beautiful girl like her pulls it off especially with that bright red lip color and crystal blue eyes.”

Our humble opinion: “One word: awful. It looks like a wig, is she trying to hide from the paparazzi?” — Anna, Assistant Editor

“It’s too ‘shoe polish black’ to match her skin tone.” — Molly, Associate Editor